Viacom's massive lawsuit over alleged intellectual property abuses on YouTube has taken a turn that may affect the privacy of visitors to the video-sharing Web site. The judge in the case has ruled that Google must turn over detailed logs including individual user IDs and information on the videos they watched.
A new ruling in Viacom's (NYSE: VIAb) US$1 billion lawsuit against Google (Nasdaq: GOOG) has privacy advocates fretting that the case may further erode privacy online, even if it's eventually settled.
Judge Louis Stanton of the U.S. District Court for Southern New York ruled that Google must provide Viacom with information from its database, including users' YouTube login IDs, the videos they watched, and the time they watched them.
Viacom wants the data in order to rebut Google's claim that user traffic to copyrighted content on YouTube is just a small part of the site's overall traffic. Last year, Viacom sued Google, alleging that it allowed nearly 160,000 copyrighted clips to be viewed on the popular video-sharing Web site without authorization.
Google hit back with a multi-pronged rebuttal: It invoked the DMCA's safe harbor provision; argued that users create their own content from the disputed material; and contended that Viacom would be stifling the free exchange of information by restricting its use.
By requesting the user information, Viacom hopes to cut off the legs of Google's main argument, said Kevin Levy, co-chair of Gunster Yoakley's technology and emerging growth companies practice groups.
"Viacom appears to be looking for evidence to support its claim that one, maybe Google isn't taking videos down properly, and two, that copyright-protected content is being viewed more than user-generated work," Levy told the E-Commerce Times.
Given that the case hinges on whether Google is financially benefiting from the viewing of copyrighted material on YouTube, it is understandable that the judge ordered it to turn over user information to Viacom as part of discovery, he said.
What's surprising is the extent of the judge's ruling. In such cases, aggregated information typically would be enough. "Google could provide data that shows a certain video was watched 1 million times, 64 percent of the viewers were male, and viewers were spread out across the country," Levy suggested.
Giving Viacom the right to pick through the details of individual viewers' habits on YouTube, he said, "is what has the privacy advocates up in arms. This is a big issue for them."
Print Version
E-Mail Article
Reprints
More by Erika Morphy
Next Article in Law
|
Are the Feds Stalking Your Cell Phone? Lawsuit Seeks Answers July 02, 2008 
Is the federal government using people's own cell phones to track their movements? It's a question two privacy groups want answered, and they've filed a lawsuit seeking to force the U.S. Department of Justice to cough it up.
|
Related Stories
|
Viacom v. Google Wends Its Way Through Legal Fog May 28, 2008 
Viacom's billion-dollar litigation over Google's use of its copyrighted material on YouTube may skirt the legal thicket it seems bound for. The companies may find that it's in their better interests not to press for clarification of the murky laws surrounding their arguments and opt to settle the case instead.
|
YouTube to Lieberman: Censor This May 20, 2008 
It's amazing to see just how far Joe Lieberman has strayed from his former persona. First, the one-time Democratic nominee for vice president left his party; now he appears to be forsaking the Constitution.
|
Related News Alerts
More by Erika Morphy
|
Windows 7 Flies Off the Shelves November 06, 2009 
Early sales figures on Windows 7 boxed software suggest a high level of consumer enthusiasm for the OS. Unit sales were a whopping 234 percent higher than Vista's out of the gate. The revenue haul was not as impressive, as Microsoft offered sharp discounts to spur presales. Also, sales of PCs with Windows 7 preinstalled have been lackluster -- but October is historically a weak month for PC sales.
|
Southwest Doesn't Fool Around November 06, 2009 
Either Southwest Airlines had better deals for my favorite route than its competitors or its superior Web site tools made it easier for me to ferret them out. Either way, kudos to Southwest. In the not-so-hot department were the airline's long list of what passengers weren't allowed to do and its very short list of what Southwest was obliged to do for them. Left me feeling a little chilly.
|
Commerce Search Puts Google Inside Retailers' Catalogs November 05, 2009 
Google has launched a new cloud-based search tool targeting enterprise-level e-commerce operations, just in time for the 2009 holiday selling season. Commerce Search provides a set of features designed to improve the relevance of results for consumers searching a retailer's own product catalog, while boosting cross-selling opportunities.
|
Get Business and Technology News Alerts
Most Popular | Spotlight Features | Exclusives
This Week on ECT News Network | Podcasts
WiFi Hotspot Locator 
Inside TechNewsWorld
|
Reader Services
|
Corporate
|
Headline Feeds
Talkback: 
