By Jennifer LeClaire LinuxInsider Part of the ECT News Network
07/15/05 9:37 AM PT
Stacey Quandt, senior business analyst and Open Source Practice leader at the
Robert Frances Group, told LinuxInsider that the situation has little to do with e-mails. It's about proof. That's what convinces a judge, she stressed.
A 2002 e-mail claims a SCO Group investigation failed to uncover any evidence that Linux contained copyrighted Unix code.
Groklaw yesterday posted an e-mail dated August 2002 penned by SCO Group engineer Michael Davidson. The message allegedly made its way to one of the company's senior vice presidents and then on to SCO Group CEO Darl McBride.
SCO filed a US$1 billion suit against IBM (NYSE: IBM) in 2003, alleging that Big Blue infringed on its proprietary Unix code. SCO's multibillion-dollar Unix patent lawsuits also include Novell, AutoZone and Daimler Chrysler.
Inside the Controversy
Davidson's e-mail said, "The project was a result of SCO's executive management refusing to believe that it was possible for Linux and much of the GNU software to have come into existence without someone somewhere having copied pieces of proprietary UNIX source code."
"The hope was that we would find a 'smoking gun' somwhere (sic) in code that was being used by Red Hat (NYSE: RHT) and/or the other Linux companies that would give us some leverage."
The e-mail did not disclose details of the investigation; however, Davidson did note that it was conducted by Bob Swartz, a consultant SCO hired.
"An outside consultant was brought in because I had already voiced the opinion (based on very detailed knowledge of our own source code and reasonably broad exposure to Linux and other open-source projects) that it was a waste of time and we were not going to find anything," he wrote in the e-mail.
Swartz's Two Cents
Davidson's e-mail continues, noting that Swartz spent four to six months examining the Linux kernel, along with a large number of libraries and utilities in order to compare them to various versions of AT&T's (NYSE: T) Unix source code.
Swartz discovered there was some code that was identical to Unix and other code. He also noted that the code appeared to be rewritten in a possible attempt to disguise the plagiarism. Swartz described the identical code as "fragments" rather than an entire program.
"The fact, however, that there are pieces of code which are identical to those in the Unix source and others which appear to be simply a rewriting of Unix code is clearly disturbing," Swartz wrote in his e-mail.
SCO Responds
"This memo shows that Mr. Davidson's e-mail is referring to an investigation limited to literal copying, which is not the standard for copyright violations, and which can be avoided by deliberate obfuscation, as the memo itself points out," said a statement SCO released yesterday.
"Even more importantly, this memo shows that there are problems with Linux. It also notes that additional investigation is required to locate all of the problems, which SCO has been continuing in discovery in the IBM and AutoZone cases," the statement continued.
"Thus, even aside from the fact that SCO's central contract claims in the IBM litigation involve later Linux versions and different conduct, it would simply be inaccurate -- and misleading -- to use Mr. Davidson's e-mail to suggest that SCO's internal investigation revealed no problems."
Waiting for a Verdict
Stacey Quandt, senior business analyst and Open Source Practice leader at the
Robert Frances Group, told LinuxInsider that the situation has little to do with e-mails. It's about proof: That's what convinces a judge, she said.
"Regardless of SCO's latest statement, nothing is proven until a judge rules in this case," Quandt said. "SCO has a history. They threatened, then sued their own customers. Part of this case is about whether there was real copying that went on. That still remains to be proven."
The case is scheduled to go to trial in early 2007.
Sun 'Open-Sources' Its Authentication Technology July 14, 2005
Sun also announced it has created an OpenSSO community Web site. OpenSSO is designed to provide developers with project information and resources to foster discussion and facilitate participation in the community, including: roadmaps, FAQs, documentation,
tutorials, sample code and mailing lists.
Related Stories
Adoption of Alternate E-Mail Security Technologies Pushed June 25, 2005
"Each protocol provides different answers to different problems involving e-mail security issues. But both new protocols deal with sender authentication," Thomas Gillis, senior vice president for worldwide marketing at IronPort Systems, said.
SCOing, SCOing, Gone? March 23, 2005
SCO's woes are a cautionary tale -- not because SCO is evil, or because SCO is anti-Linux, or because its CEO tried a lawsuit in the press -- all of which are unfortunate, or in the latter case, annoying. SCO is failing as a business because its products are failing in the marketplace.
Price of Free Internet Mail Might Be Too Costly January 27, 2005
The term "free e-mail," however, means one thing to e-mail operators and quite another to consumers and businesses who accept the come-on for a free e-mail account. So-called free e-mail accounts are not truly free. Users often pay for the mail service without parting with their dollars and cents.
Poker and Shell Games in the SCO Suit June 01, 2004
SCO is betting that the threat of litigation will force companies to pay licensing fees. SCO does not want the shells to stop moving because if companies see that there are no coins under any of the shells, the game will be over.
Linux vs. Longhorn: The Battle Is Joined May 10, 2004
Microsoft's image isn't what it once was. Much like it was with client-server computing and IBM, the IT audience is actively exploring Linux as a desktop option. There are trials backed by vendors like IBM and HP springing up all over the globe. Governments seem particularly enamored with the offering, which is an important development because governments set standards.
Related News Alerts
More by Jennifer LeClaire
The Digital Car: Cool Automotive Accessories, Part 2 January 16, 2007
Not all the latest high-tech automotive electronics are built to entertain. Many give the driver more information and more control. Vehicle tracking devices can tell where the car is at any time, software installed in a smartphone can turn off a vehicle's security system whenever the owner approaches, and diagnostic tools can tell what's wrong with the engine -- and how much it'll be to fix it.
'World of Warcraft' Wows 8 Million Subscribers January 12, 2007
"World of Warcraft," the massively multiplayer online role-playing game, has reached the 8 million subscriber mark. Since debuting in North America in Nov. 2004, "World of Warcraft" has become the most popular MMORPG in the world. The franchise is available in seven different languages and is played on at least four continents.
AT&T Bids Goodbye to Cingular Brand January 12, 2007
Starting Monday, AT&T will launch a multimedia campaign to transition the Cingular Wireless brand name into its advertising and customer communications. The campaign will integrate popular imagery, phrases and icons from Cingular's traditional advertising, including the "raising the bar" tagline, the "Jack" character and the color orange.