By Sonia Arrison TechNewsWorld
07/25/08 4:00 AM PT
Republican presidential candidate John McCain has admitted that he isn't the most Web-savvy person, and he's even gone as far as saying he's "an illiterate" when it comes to the Internet. However, TechNewsWorld columnist Sonia Arrison questions: Does this all really matter?
When it comes to the Internet, Republican presidential candidate John McCain recently said that he's "an illiterate who has to rely on his wife for any assistance he can get." In an era where the Internet is playing an ever greater role, does such an admission matter, and does it say anything important about the age gap between McCain and Democratic candidate Barack Obama?
This is not the first time a politician has come under fire for sweeping claims about the Internet. Recall, for instance, Al Gore's comment that he "took the initiative in creating the Internet." Everyone knows that DARPA (the Defense Advanced Research Projects Agency) drove the creation of the Net, not the former vice president, but his comment made for many jokes on late-night shows.
McCain, of course, made quite the opposite assertion, but is he really the "illiterate" he mentioned or is something else going on? His campaign aides say he's fully capable of browsing the Web and that he has a Mac and uses it several times a week. Senator McCain will get "hip points" for using a Mac; nevertheless, he clearly doesn't think being Internet savvy is an important branding strategy . This may bother some, but many politically active technology entrepreneurs don't seem to be upset.
Shunning the Net?
For instance, Silicon Valley-based technology investor Anurag Chandra says McCain's indifference to using the Internet is a factor voters should consider, "but one of several and lower in priority than his stance on policies that affect technology innovation in the U.S.
"What he promotes is more important to me than what is exemplified by his individual proclivities," Chandra says.
Good point, because creating an environment that fosters innovation is more important than having a president who wastes time surfing the Net. This helps explain support for McCain from high-profile technology leaders such as Cisco's (Nasdaq: CSCO) John Chambers and Meg Whitman, eBay's (Nasdaq: EBAY) former CEO. Yet not everyone is comfortable with the idea of a presidential candidate who shuns the Net.
Role Models
Participation and understanding of technology are very important, notes LinkedIn founder Reid Hoffman. Understanding is indeed key, and this brings up the nagging question of whether the age gap between McCain and Senator Obama matters at all. On this issue, Hoffman points out that ability matters more than age.
Indeed, many of the most successful Internet companies have been started by young guns without much experience. Steve Jobs and Steve Wozniak started Apple (Nasdaq: AAPL) in their early 20s -- the same age as Bill Gates and Paul Allen when they started Microsoft (Nasdaq: MSFT), and Sergey Brin and Larry Page launched Google (Nasdaq: GOOG) in their mid-20s. When it comes to young technology entrepreneurs, the list could go on. Of course, world affairs do reach farther than Silicon Valley or Redmond.
When it comes to wealth and success , many of America's role models are older and more experienced. Consider that at 77, Warren Buffett is still making great investment decisions and Rupert Murdoch is still building his media empire. Also, at 74, Larry King is still capturing fascinating interviews.
Finding Answers
So, perhaps it really doesn't matter how old someone is or how much time they spend surfing the Web. Perhaps one of the most important things that voters and the tech community should be considering is what kind of people the commander-in-chief chooses to be around him. That's something that will be easier to find given the Web 2.0 boom, says David Kralik of American Solutions.
"Technology is holding politicians more accountable with the ability to check facts about previous statements they may have made and who their donors are," says Kralik. A perfect example of this was Hillary Clinton's story about landing in sniper fire during a 1996 trip to Bosnia. The public discovered she stretched the truth when a YouTube video surfaced showing Hillary and daughter Chelsea, on that very trip, walking across the tarmac smiling and stopping to shake hands with Bosnia's acting president.
Regardless of how much time McCain spends online, over the next few months, the Internet will be most important in helping voters find detailed answers about each candidate and their team.
Sonia Arrison, a TechNewsWorld columnist, is senior fellow in technology studies at the California-based Pacific Research Institute.
Facebook Tags Best Apps, Springs User Data July 24, 2008
Two new Facebook programs are designed to change the functions and versatility of the social networking platform. The Great Apps program spotlights Facebook applications that are particularly useful and noteworthy, rather than the spammy junk users often complain about. Facebook Connect will let users carry their identities to other third-party Web sites, applications and devices.
Related Stories
Election 2008: The Role of Radio August 27, 2007
"We think that the variety of candidates and issues in this election makes the idea of a channel dedicated solely to it appealing," said David Butler, senior director of corporate affairs at XM Radio. The presidential election channel, which will be available free to all subscribers, will feature news updates, candidate interviews, speeches, debate coverage, live call-in shows and podcasts.
YouTube to Flex Political Muscle With CNN Presidential Debate July 23, 2007
Anderson Cooper and CNN will host a presidential debate Monday night, but YouTubers will be the ones asking the questions. For weeks, YouTube users have been posting videos of themselves posing questions they want asked during the Democratic Party candidate debate. A similar debate among Republican Party candidates is scheduled for September.
YouTube Presidential Debates - a Sea Change for US Politics? June 15, 2007
"In our new age of blogs, wikis, shared video via YouTube, and mashups, bringing Web 2.0 technologies to the political process gives potential constituents a larger role in the presidential candidate-selling process -- a much more direct role than MoveOn.org and Meetups did for the last presidential election," said Robb Hecht, adjunct marketing professor with the City University of New York.
Related News Alerts
More by Sonia Arrison
How to Solve the Net Neutrality Issue October 28, 2009
Regulation by the U.S. government is not the way to keep the Internet neutral. A better approach would be self-regulation. Now is the time for ISPs to support an independent, private body to monitor neutrality issues and forestall the possibility of the FCC "managing competition" on the Internet.
FCC's Genachowski Not Neutral on New Net Rules September 30, 2009
The proponents of Net neutrality say it's necessary for a free and open Internet, but history doesn't support that argument. The Telecommunications Act of 1996, for example, was supposed to bolster competition. Instead, by compelling companies to share their infrastructures, it reduced incentives for improvement. In the long run, it failed.
What Has President Obama Done for Silicon Valley? August 28, 2009
President Obama's appointments of Silicon Valley outsiders were only the first indications that his administration would be less than friendly to the high-tech industry, despite campaign promises. Since then, it has shown an inclination toward tight regulatory practices and away from transparency.