Battlefield 1 Balances Gaming Fun With WW1 Realism

The latest title in the long-running Battlefield series made its debut last week. Instead of another near-future setting with the latest high-tech body armor and assault weapons, DICE and Electronic Arts are putting players in the trenches of the First World War and outfitting them with bolt-action rifles, horses, and gas masks.

The series, which launched in 2001 with the World War 2-themed Battlefield 1942, has moved forward in time up to now, with a sequel set during the Vietnam War and subsequent follow-ups set in the modern day or even in the future.

The Battlefield series is notable in that it added controllable vehicles — from tanks to planes and later helicopters and even ships — to the mix. Over time, it also introduced destructive environments to heighten the mayhem.

This time around, with Battlefield 1, players will find themselves on the Western Front. However, there’s also action set in the wider-reaching war, including campaigns in the Italian Alps and even the deserts of Arabia.

Period-authentic weapons, armaments, vehicles, and steeds will be controllable by the players, with up to 64 able to engage in multiplayer online battles.


“When we first started building this game, we knew that we wanted to do something new — something that allowed us to do more unique gameplay and that felt fresh and varied to the players and ourselves,” said Aleksander Grndal, senior producer at DICE.

“The idea of a World War 1 Battlefield game had been around for many years in the studio and something we had wanted to do for a while,” Grndaltold TechNewsWorld. “When we matched up the requirements, it was a perfect fit — the right idea at the right time, essentially.”

Battlefield 1 will launch on Oct. 21, 2016, for Microsoft’s XboxOne and Sony’s PlayStation 4, as well as via EA’s Origin service for the PC.

Not So Static Warfare

The most common perception of the First World War is of static trench lines — something movies such as All Quiet on the Western Front and Paths of Glory helped instill in the popular mythos.

To date, few games have sought to replicate that experience. Most notable among them is the independently produced first-person shooter Verdun. Now, though, it seems that DICE/EA will attempt to deliver a Battlefield version of that experience.

There’s plenty of scope for a variety of settings and narratives, as World War 1 was fought on three continents.

That said, “when creating a game, we always look for fun over 100 percent authentic, so in some cases, we make take creative liberties for the better of the experience,” Grndal said.

“On the other hand, we also want to show that this era was more than rifles and trench warfare and that it took place in more interesting locations — like the deserts of Arabia and the Italian alps and more,” he added. “Our goal is to show as much variety as we possibly can and also challenge the preconceptions about what it was. In that, we believe that we can have the gameplay variety needed and be authentic as well.”

Truly a World War

Early responses from the gaming community have been strong.

“My first reaction was as someone who really liked the recent Nova program on excavated trenches in Belgium,” said George T. Chronis, game industry analyst at DFC Intelligence.

Although “it really is impossible to speculate on potential reception based on so little information,” he told TechNewsWorld, “as I am seeing screens of aerial dogfights, zeppelins, and Arab light horses, this may not be the static affair you are expecting.”

It’s unlikely that many gamers play Battlefield to simulate a real-world experience, said Lewis Ward, research director for gaming at IDC.

However, if EA is smart, it will emulate the way wars were fought during a given period, he told TechNewsWorld.

DICE/EA could “redefine shooters by reimposing technical constraints on what weapons can do,” Ward suggested. “This is the aspect of warfare that is vital if they get it right — and if they do, this game has the potential to become an ongoing series in its own right.”

Less-Known Affair

When the wave of World War 2-themed shooters came out — Medal of Honor and Call of Duty, among others — there already was a lot of of renewed interest in the tales of the Greatest Generation reflected in movies and TV shows, such as HBO’s epic miniseries Band of Brothers.

DICE is taking a gamble, as there is hardly that level of public consciousness about World War 1, even though this year marks the 100th anniversary of some of the war’s most terrible fighting, including the battles of Verdun and the Somme.

“While movies such as Saving Private Ryan helped spur the success ofWW2 games, they won’t have been the only driver behind the movement,” said Steve Bailey, senior analyst for games at IHS Technology.

“There was also the fact that games hardware was becoming sufficiently advanced as to be able to render striking first-person representations of various battlefields from across the 20th century,” he told TechNewsWorld.

“As the hardware progressed even further, Battlefield and Call Of Duty would go on to tackle modern-day or near-future scenarios, making everything bigger, busier, and more intense,” Bailey noted.

Back to the Trenches and Beyond

Despite the risks inherent in delivering a game set in World War 1 rather than in the modern day, that choice could be a way for the franchise to stand apart from Activision’s Call of Duty, which has focused heavily on modern times.

Battlefield 1 itself could spur interest in World War 1, just as Battlefield 1942 and Medal of Honor helped draw attention to World War 2.

“It does seem that the BF1 debut trailer has generally been well-received,” observed Bailey.

Of course, it is still a game and one that needs to be fun — even if it is set during one of the most horrific and tragic periods of the 20th century.

“DICE will take some liberties with Battlefield 1, but the prospect of them applying the audiovisual impact of modern gaming platforms toWW1 is actually something that’s interesting to me,” Bailey said.”Perhaps the older machinery and technology — and less intensely urban settings — will mean that moments of danger feel all the more furious and convincing.”

Worldwide Potential

If the gamble to set Battlefield 1 in World War 1 pays off, it could open the door for a number of expansion packs and sequels, especially as the long, drawn-out conflict spread across a much wider geography than the Western Front.

“I could do a whole game on the German East Africa campaign, and that is as far away from static as you can get for that war,” suggested Chronis.

However, Battlefield 1 may have to tone down some of the more horrific historical elements to be an enjoyable game, and the developers will have to stay politically neutral — something the game developers discovered when making the Germans playable in World War 2 shooters in the multiplayer mode.

“The problem with WW1 is that there is so much carnage for so little gain that most storytelling centered on the conflict tends to getpolitical: All Quiet On the Western Front, The Eagle and the Hawk, Grand Illusion, Gallipoli, etc.,” Chronis noted.

“Politics is something EA probably would rather steer clear of,” he said, but although”there is a lot about WW1 that can be shared to help people today better understand what happened and why, I doubt a Battlefield title will travel very far down that road, and that’s a shame.”

Avoiding controversy while delivering a solid game will be DICE’sprimary goal, especially as it continues to compete with Call of Duty in the action gaming genre.

“Battlefield is a key shooter franchise and a marquis brand for EA,” said IDC’s Ward. “What’s at stake is the reputation of a franchise that has generated billions of dollars over the years.”

Peter Suciu is a freelance writer who has covered consumer electronics, technology, electronic entertainment and fitness-related trends for more than a decade. His work has appeared in more than three dozen publications, and he is the co-author of Careers in the Computer Game Industry (Career in the New Economy series), a career guide aimed at high school students from Rosen Publishing. You can connect with Peter on Google+.

Leave a Comment

Please sign in to post or reply to a comment. New users create a free account.

More by Peter Suciu
More in Gaming

Technewsworld Channels