Technology Debuts Legit Music Downloads – Strings Attached

A new legal music download service for PCs has been unveiled, boasting the largest legitimate online catalog of songs to date, but still might be hampered because it lacks the freedom offered by free file-sharing networks, experts said.

Aliso Viejo, California-based will sell tracks from its growing list of 300,000 songs starting at 79 cents each, with albums selling for US$7.95, the company announced at the service’s launch.

While the service has the largest legitimate music library and the lowest price of comparable licensed music download sites, such as MusicNow, MusicNet, Rhapsody and Pressplay, still limits what users can do with music files once they are downloaded.

That could limit popularity of the new PC download offering and prevent users of free file-sharing services, such as Kazaa and Grokster — which allow downloaders unlimited copying to any device or to CDs – from switching to the legitimate alternative.

Large and Legal founder and CEO Scott Blum said the new site is aimed at turning the music industry “right side up.”

Blum claimed that no other site is legally offering the magnitude of tracks that will make available. He added that the site has the backing of the recording industry and will deliver music from the top five record labels as well as independent labels.

Still, Yankee Group senior analyst Mike Goodman told TechNewsWorld that the new site’s music library does not come close to the millions of tracks – which include live performances, studio versions and remakes – available on the free P2P networks.

Limited License

Despite its large music catalog, lack of monthly subscription fees and option to preview music through 30-second samples, limits what downloaders can do with the tracks and albums they purchase through the site.

Users are limited in terms of the number of times they can copy a song and where they can copy it. They must register each device they plan to use for downloading, according to the site’s terms. Goodman said such restrictions are likely to limit use of the new site.

“Every hoop you make the consumer jump through lowers your acceptance rate,” he said.

Wrong Format

The site will deliver tracks via Microsoft Windows Media. There is no monthly subscription fee, and the site will store purchase information to bill users’ credit cards as they make purchases, the company said.

While Blum claimed “the new buzz phrase is no longer MP3 players,” referring instead to digital music players, Yankee’s Goodman said the contrary is true. He pointed out that MP3 is still the digital format of choice for online music fans.

Goodman added that the recording industry is resisting the use of MP3 in part because of its portability, but also because it has become synonymous with file trading.

Endangered by Endorsement boasted “100 percent” backing from the recording industry, but Goodman said that endorsement might represent a counter-cultural force that could hinder the new site.

“It’s certainly not going to be beneficial,” he said. “Users are going to say the authority figures endorsed this one.”

The site also won the approval and praise of the Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), which recently came under fire for pursuing legal action against individual users of free P2P applications.

Face-Off With Free

Nielsen//NetRatings senior analyst Greg Bloom told TechNewsWorld that legitimate sites such as MusicNow are still lagging far behind the free P2P networks in terms of user numbers.

“The use of the free services is just infinitely bigger than the use of legitimate, paid download services,” Bloom said.

Although Apple has been successful with its iTunes online music store, which sells tracks for 99 cents each, Apple represents only a small subsection of the residential PC market, according to Bloom. appears to be a PC version of iTunes — with a lower price — but Bloom said legitimate services are still a long way from competing with free services in terms of use.

“It doesn’t appear that people are going to stop using services like Kazaa,” he noted.

1 Comment

  • Thumbs down on the author of this story. Really. Have we become such a "free-at-all-costs" e-society with near-religious zealotry (and hackers as our patron saints) that the specter of a legitimate music service is looked upon with such obvious disdain?
    I was really offended that even as you tried to present’s chief value offering, you couldn’t even do THAT without presenting it in a negative light.
    While it may be true that there are contrasts between this service and the illegal free share services before it, the fact that has indeed built a substantial AND legitmate alternative with a very attractive consumer value proposition should have been something to lift up as a shining example of what should be (or at least has the potential to be); instead you took an implied position of "this will probably fail, because it isn’t free."
    Now, to be true, I’ve been in the online since well before it was the internet, and have gloriously and greedily pursued and accepted free media in all its evolutions for at least the past fifteen years or so. So it would be wrong to characterize me as a music or movie exec or legal wonk trying to control the internet.
    On the contrary; I was put off enough by the quite negative angle (beyond the level of skepticism a business writer is normally afforded) you took.
    If you are to be a fair journalist, be objective. Look at the benefits for what they bring, and feel free to share your skepticism. Hey, I think your "Napster Lifetime Membership" card just fell out of your pocket. You might want to pick that up.

Leave a Comment

Please sign in to post or reply to a comment. New users create a free account.

Technewsworld Channels